Giants 2025 NFL Tommy DeVito Roundup: Will New York Trade Up for QB or Take Best Available at No. 3?
As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the New York Giants face a pivotal decision regarding their quarterback position. The team has undergone significant changes over the past few seasons, and while they’ve shown flashes of competitiveness, the question of who will lead the franchise in the long-term remains uncertain. With the Giants holding the third overall pick in the upcoming draft, they have a chance to reshape the future of their offense. However, whether they’ll use this high selection to secure a quarterback, trade up for a more coveted prospect, or take the best available player is a matter that has generated plenty of discussion.
**Tommy DeVito’s Current Standing with the Giants**
Tommy DeVito, a young quarterback who has been on the Giants’ roster, has shown some promise in limited opportunities. As of now, DeVito is seen as more of a developmental player than a future starter. While he has demonstrated some upside, especially with his mobility and arm strength, DeVito’s inconsistencies have led many to question whether he’s the long-term solution for the Giants at the quarterback position.
With veteran Daniel Jones under contract for the next few seasons, DeVito could serve as a backup or developmental option. However, the organization needs to carefully evaluate his potential in comparison to other available quarterbacks in the draft, especially given the opportunity presented by the No. 3 pick. If DeVito were to impress during the offseason and earn a larger role, the Giants could decide to focus on bolstering other areas of the roster. However, if they feel DeVito hasn’t shown enough growth, it may prompt the front office to seek out a more proven option via trade or draft.
**The Quarterback Draft Class of 2025**
The 2025 quarterback class is expected to be strong, with a handful of elite prospects who could be immediate contributors. Players like Caleb Williams from USC, Drake Maye from North Carolina, and others are highly regarded as potential franchise quarterbacks. Williams, in particular, is a player that many analysts consider a generational talent, with his blend of athleticism, accuracy, and leadership. Maye, on the other hand, is another impressive talent known for his strong arm and high football IQ. Given the state of the Giants’ roster, the team would likely be interested in one of these quarterbacks if they were available at No. 3.
However, the Giants may not be in a position to wait for the top quarterbacks to fall to them. Given the potential for other teams to target these quarterbacks, New York might explore the idea of trading up to secure a top pick. Teams at the top of the draft will undoubtedly be jockeying for position, and the Giants could find themselves in a bidding war for a chance to land their quarterback of the future.
**Trading Up or Staying Put?**
The dilemma for the Giants is whether they should trade up for a quarterback or stay put at No. 3 and select the best available player. Trading up would likely require giving up future draft picks, but it would also provide the chance to secure one of the top quarterbacks in this class. This would signal a commitment to a new era, as the team would be prioritizing a long-term solution at the most important position in football.
On the other hand, staying at No. 3 could allow the Giants to grab a premium player at a different position. If the top quarterbacks are off the board by the time the Giants pick, they could choose to select a game-changing wide receiver, offensive lineman, or defensive playmaker. Adding such a player could bolster the overall roster and help the team build a more balanced unit, potentially setting up a young quarterback for success down the road. The Giants’ defense, for example, has several promising young pieces, and adding a top-tier offensive weapon might elevate the team to a higher competitive level.
**The Key to the Decision**
The decision will ultimately come down to how much confidence the Giants have in DeVito and the future of their quarterback room. If they view DeVito as a potential starter, they may opt for a more measured approach, using their third overall pick to improve other areas of the roster. However, if they’re uncertain about DeVito’s trajectory or feel that they need a higher-caliber quarterback to compete in a tough NFC East division, then trading up could be the move that defines the franchise’s future for the next decade.
In either case, the 2025 NFL Draft promises to be a critical juncture for the New York Giants, with the potential to either secure a new quarterback of the future or continue to build around the talent already in place. The outcome will depend on how the team evaluates both its current quarterback situation and the draft’s available prospects.
Leave a Reply