Phillies could add high-priced slugger to replace Alec Bohm on the hot corner

 

 

The Philadelphia Phillies are always looking for ways to improve their roster, particularly when it comes to bolstering their offense. One area of interest for the team in recent seasons has been third base, a position that has seen mixed results despite Alec Bohm’s steady presence. While Bohm has shown flashes of potential, the Phillies have not yet seen the consistent offensive production they need from the hot corner to take them over the top. In response, rumors have swirled that the Phillies could add a high-priced slugger to replace Bohm at third base.

Replacing Bohm, a player with plenty of upside, would not be an easy decision. However, when a team has playoff aspirations like the Phillies, especially after their deep run in the 2022 postseason, the front office must prioritize performance over potential. The move to sign or trade for a high-priced slugger would be in line with the team’s aggressive approach to improving their roster.

**Bohm’s Performance: A Mixed Bag**

regular third baseman. His hitting ability, particularly in terms of contact and bat-to-ball skills, has been a positive. In 2021, Bohm finished with a respectable .247 batting average, a solid .302 on-base percentage, and a 102 OPS+. However, his power numbers were below expectations, and his defense was often a point of concern.

In 2022, Bohm showed slight improvements, finishing with a .280 batting average and a .315 on-base percentage. However, his power output remained limited, with just 13 home runs and 72 RBIs. Defensively, Bohm’s metrics remained subpar. He has shown a good glove in stretches, but his range and arm strength have been questioned. The Phillies’ front office likely feels that the team would benefit from more consistent production both offensively and defensively from the hot corner.

Bohm’s inability to reach his potential as a power hitter and his inconsistent defense have likely led the Phillies to consider alternatives, especially when examining the opportunities available in free agency or via trade. The Phillies could look to upgrade their roster with a proven high-priced slugger who could provide a more consistent offensive threat in the middle of their lineup.

**High-Priced Sluggers Available**

There are several potential high-priced options available for the Phillies if they look to make a splash in the free-agent market or explore trade options. These players would add not only power but also stability to the Phillies’ lineup, making them a potential threat to go deeper into the playoffs.

1. **Matt Chapman (Free Agent)**: One of the top third basemen on the market, Matt Chapman has long been known for his power and elite defense. Chapman has consistently posted 30+ home run seasons with the Oakland Athletics and Toronto Blue Jays. In 2023, Chapman had a 4.6 WAR, showcasing his value both offensively and defensively. His power would provide the Phillies with a much-needed boost in the middle of the lineup, and his elite defense at third base would be a vast upgrade over Bohm’s range and throwing accuracy.

2. **Nolan Arenado (Trade Target)**: Arenado is one of the best all-around third basemen in baseball. A perennial Gold Glove and Silver Slugger winner, Arenado has power, excellent defense, and consistency. His contract is a bit more complicated with his long-term deal with the St. Louis Cardinals, but the Phillies could explore the possibility of trading for him. Arenado’s bat would complement the Phillies’ offense, especially in a lineup with players like Bryce Harper and J.T. Realmuto. His defense would shore up the hot corner and solidify the infield.

3. **Josh Donaldson (Trade or Free Agent)**: Once a premier slugger in the league, Josh Donaldson remains a potent offensive threat, though he has shown some decline in recent seasons. If the Phillies are looking for a one-year, high-risk, high-reward option, Donaldson could fit the bill. While his defense may not be what it once was, his bat remains dangerous in the right circumstances. The Phillies could sign him to a short-term deal while keeping their options open for future seasons.

4. **Eugenio Suárez (Trade Target)**: Suárez, currently with the Seattle Mariners, has been a steady power hitter at third base for years. While his defense isn’t as elite as some of the other options, his offensive production has been impressive, with multiple seasons of 30+ home runs. Suárez could be a cheaper alternative to Chapman or Arenado, making him an intriguing option for the Phillies to explore via trade. If they’re looking to upgrade without breaking the bank, Suárez could be an affordable solution.

**Why the Phillies Could Make a Move**

The Phillies have shown a willingness to spend on big-ticket players in recent seasons, most notably signing Bryce Harper and J.T. Realmuto to long-term contracts. Given that the team has championship aspirations, the front office may be more inclined to spend money on a high-priced slugger to address a position of need.

Another factor in the Phillies’ decision-making process is the team’s current roster. With Harper, Realmuto, Kyle Schwarber, and other key contributors in place, the team’s window for winning is now. The Phillies made it to the 2022 World Series, and a similar performance in 2023 will only increase the urgency to add talent. Adding a proven power hitter to replace Bohm at third base could provide the extra edge needed to push the team over the top.

Additionally, the Phillies’ farm system has produced several promising prospects, but the team is likely more interested in competing in the present rather than waiting for future prospects to develop. Trading for a high-priced slugger could be a move that bolsters the team’s chances without having to rely too much on unproven talent.

**What This Move Would Mean for the Phillies**

Replacing Bohm with a high-priced slugger would have several ramifications for the Phillies’ roster. Offensively, it would bring more power and consistency to the hot corner, which would help the team as they look to outslug opponents in a high-powered NL East. It would also take some pressure off Harper and Schwarber, as the team would no longer rely on just two players to generate runs.

Defensively, a more experienced and skilled third baseman would provide stability in the infield. Players like Arenado or Chapman would not only improve the defense at third base but also allow the team to be more confident in turning double plays and limiting extra-base hits down the line.

**Conclusion**

The Phillies are in a position where they need to continue improving their roster to compete for a World Series title. While Alec Bohm has potential, his inconsistent performance at both the plate and in the field may leave the Phillies looking for a more established option at third base. A high-priced slugger could be the solution. With several strong candidates available in both free agency and via trade, the Phillies could look to acquire a player who will bring consistent power and defense to the hot corner. As the team continues to push for a championship, adding a proven star at third base could be the missing piece needed to put them over the top.